2quik4u
Posts: 4,388
Jan 29, 2010 3:00pm
3reppom
Posts: 765
Jan 29, 2010 4:10pm
the two Miami classes need to be higher, particularly the 84 class
2quik4u
Posts: 4,388
Jan 29, 2010 5:29pm
yea I agree with this3reppom wrote: the two Miami classes need to be higher, particularly the 84 class
2quik4u
Posts: 4,388
Jan 29, 2010 5:30pm
Florida is way to high
darbypitcher22
Posts: 8,000
Jan 29, 2010 7:47pm
I agree on the Miami list....
i forgot OSU's '98 class had some of those guys in it... pretty impressive number there if you ask me
i forgot OSU's '98 class had some of those guys in it... pretty impressive number there if you ask me
S
sjmvsfscs08
Posts: 2,963
Jan 29, 2010 10:57pm
Was Tom Lemming around in 1946? That class had one of the greatest runs in history. Do I think they stack up anywhere near #1 compared to today? Hell no. I think Miami's 1999 class was #1.
E
Eric Taylor
Posts: 602
Jan 29, 2010 11:02pm
2 BCS National Championships2quik4u wrote: Florida is way to high
2 SEC Championships
1 Heisman Trophy
3-1 in Bowls(3-0 in BCS Bowls)
48-7 overall record
Argubly the greatest CFB player ever
If anything....they should be higher
Pick6
Posts: 14,946
Jan 29, 2010 11:15pm
i lol'dEric Taylor wrote:2 BCS National Championships2quik4u wrote: Florida is way to high
2 SEC Championships
1 Heisman Trophy
3-1 in Bowls(3-0 in BCS Bowls)
48-7 overall record
Argubly the greatest CFB player ever
If anything....they should be higher
karen lotz
Posts: 22,284
Jan 29, 2010 11:20pm
the keyword there is arguably. You are crazy to think that he is not at least in the discussion.
S
sjmvsfscs08
Posts: 2,963
Jan 30, 2010 2:11am
Call me crazy..
hoops23
Posts: 15,696
Jan 30, 2010 6:30am
I guess I'm crazy as well..
STM (short term memory)
Every so often a "great" college player comes along who is heralded as arguably one of the greatest. In a few years, somebody else will come along and the media/people will be all over him like they were for Tebow and the same things will be said.
STM (short term memory)
Every so often a "great" college player comes along who is heralded as arguably one of the greatest. In a few years, somebody else will come along and the media/people will be all over him like they were for Tebow and the same things will be said.
R
rock_knutne
Jan 30, 2010 8:48am
I'm shocked that none of the great recruiting classes that Lou Holtz brought to ND didn't make that list. Probably other than Miami, ND cranked out a ton of NFL talent during the Holtz era.
Scarlet_Buckeye
Posts: 5,264
Jan 30, 2010 9:20am
Terrible list.
C
charliehustle14
Posts: 2,224
Jan 31, 2010 12:56am
I think OSU in 02 could have been on the list. However, the ones on the list are some great classes so it's understandable.
Hawk, Mangold, Holmes, and Carpenter all 1st round picks. Clarett was a beast his only year at OSU, leading them to a title. Troy Smith went on to win a Heisman. Jay Richardson and Rob Sims are starters in the NFL. Salley, Pitcock, Hall, Datish, and Mitchell were all drafted.
If Clarett hadn't gotten in trouble and kept doing his thing on the field at OSU for 2 more years, the 02 class would definitely be worthy of being on that list. I mean, we're talking 5 1st round draft picks and quite possibly 2 Heisman winners.
Hawk, Mangold, Holmes, and Carpenter all 1st round picks. Clarett was a beast his only year at OSU, leading them to a title. Troy Smith went on to win a Heisman. Jay Richardson and Rob Sims are starters in the NFL. Salley, Pitcock, Hall, Datish, and Mitchell were all drafted.
If Clarett hadn't gotten in trouble and kept doing his thing on the field at OSU for 2 more years, the 02 class would definitely be worthy of being on that list. I mean, we're talking 5 1st round draft picks and quite possibly 2 Heisman winners.
M
Mr Pat
Posts: 519
Jan 31, 2010 3:03am
Because you touch yourself at the thought of another ND recruiting insult.ccrunner609 wrote: LOL, how did I know ND was going to be #1?
A
Al Bundy
Posts: 4,180
Jan 31, 2010 10:24am
This list is tough because many of the great teams in college are put together by have a few great recruiting classes in a row. I have to look back at almost every great team to see who was redshirted, came out early, etc.
P
paulspadafora
Posts: 20
Feb 1, 2010 3:42pm
Really? you're an idiot.2quik4u wrote: Florida is way to high
B
bulldog8
Posts: 497
Feb 1, 2010 6:03pm
Now this makes me laugh.....I disagree with the fact that Tebow is arguably the best college football player of all time, but to say that Florida is ranked too high is a joke. They were ranked 6th and arguably were the most dominant team in the last 10 years, possibly 20 years. The record speaks for itself, but 3 SEC championships and 2 National titles is legit - not to mention how easily they were dismantling their opponents. What's even more impressive is how Urban Meyer continues these amazing classes each year. Florida will easily walk away with the top recruiting class again this year and who knows how many more times he will do this in the future.2quik4u wrote: Florida is way to high
goosebumps
Posts: 1,058
Feb 1, 2010 6:44pm
I agree that Florida should be higher.
Also think that 02 Buckeyes deserve more consideration.
Also think that 02 Buckeyes deserve more consideration.
H
HeathAlum21
Posts: 363
Feb 2, 2010 1:03am
"The group would have won two BCS titles if not for a controversial pass interference call late in the 2003 Fiesta Bowl that allowed Ohio State to pull off an upset."
They never seem to mention the fact that regardless, it was a holding call. I will admit my bias as an Ohio State fan and alum, but I have never heard more whining about a call 8 years later.
They never seem to mention the fact that regardless, it was a holding call. I will admit my bias as an Ohio State fan and alum, but I have never heard more whining about a call 8 years later.