Eric Davis
Jon Daly
Michael Jordan
Randal Cunningham
Christian Laettner

Can't get it to just 5

Magic Johnson
Michael Jordan
Kareem
Hakeem
Grant Hill

Nolan Ryan
Greg Maddux
Eric Davis
Barry Larkin
Ken Griffey Jr
Reggie Jackson

Troy Polamalu
Rod Woodson
Walter Payton
Barry Sanders
Bo Jackson

Fred Couples
Payne Stewart
Tiger Woods

Carl Lewis
Usain Bolt
Flo Jo

Tony Perez
Johnny Bench
Pete Rose
Joe Morgan
Carl Yaztremski

Andra Davis
Lee Suggs
Jermone Harrison
Aaron Shea
Josh Cribbs
Pronk
Bob Wickman
Kenard Lang
Ira Newble

Commander of Awesome;1798936 wrote:Andra Davis
Lee Suggs
Jermone Harrison
Aaron Shea
Josh Cribbs
Pronk
Bob Wickman
Kenard Lang
Ira Newble

?.

Antonio Brown
Clint Dempsey
LeBron
Malkin
Alexis Sanchez

Automatik;1798941 wrote:Antonio Brown
Clint Dempsey
LeBron
Malkin
Alexis Sanchez

You make me sick.

Commander of Awesome;1798936 wrote:Andra Davis
Lee Suggs
Jermone Harrison
Aaron Shea
Josh Cribbs
Pronk
Bob Wickman
Kenard Lang
Ira Newble

Wickman?

Commander of Awesome;1798942 wrote:You make me sick.

AB not far off my top 5 football list

Ironman92;1798945 wrote:AB not far off my top 5 football list

Just the Brown and Cleveland athletes combined.

Ironman92;1798944 wrote:Wickman?

Saves leader in Tribe history.

Commander of Awesome;1798942 wrote:You make me sick.

Get well soon.

Commander of Awesome;1798947 wrote:Saves leader in Tribe history.

Just doesn't seem your type.

lol'd at Ira Newble

Peyton Manning
Justin Verlander
Miguel Cabrera
Justin Spieth
Al Kaline

Wally;1799635 wrote:Peyton Manning
Justin Verlander
Miguel Cabrera
Justin Spieth
Al Kaline

Is Justin Spieth Jordans brother?

Mulva;1799422 wrote:lol'd at Ira Newble

Me too ...........good one

Roberto Clemente
Oscar Robertson
Joe Montana
Mario Lemieux
Arnold Palmer

Stan Musial
Tommy Helms
Joe Morgan
Gary Nolan
Sonny Jurgensen
John Brodie
Bernie Kosar
Peyton Manning

Michael Jordan
Matt Hughes
Jonah Lomu
Chris Spielman
Orlando Pace

Mine all time is...

Tiger Woods
Steph Curry
Steve Yzerman
Pavel Datsyuk
Miguel Cabrera

Easy list for me, until #5

1. Peyton Manning
2. Leo Messi
3. Tiger Woods
4. Roger Federer
5. Reggie Miller

Michael Jordan
Dan Marino
Eric Davis (as a kid, but Brandon Phillips has become my favorite Red)
Lebron James
Tiger Woods

Michael Jordan
Andre Agassi
Mario Lemieux
Deion Sanders
Emmitt Smith

Michael Jordan - GOAT.
LeBron James - The most physically gifted basketball player ever.
Michael Phelps - Greatest Olympian ever, in my opinion.
Pete Sampras - Like watching Federer as well, but Pete gets the nod since he's American.
Tiger Woods - In his prime, the greatest golfer ever. Too bad that his life turned into a mess and he had a bunch of injuries.

Barry Bonds would have been on my list had he not been greedy and started taking roids even though he was already one of the greatest players of all time. Always enjoyed watching Peyton Manning because of his overall command and knowledge of the game, so he's close too. Ezekiel Elliott is probably my favorite Buckeye ever, so I look forward to watching his pro career.