Commander of Awesome;1446527 wrote:Thinking some more about Noel, the guy's PEAK weight while at Kentucky was 220, which is lighter than any top Center prospect and about 60 pounds lighter than top C's in the game right now (Marc Gasol, Howard). Then you factor where he is offensively (IMO Noah was far superior at this point in his college career compared to Noel) and is Noel going to a more dominant defender than Joakim Noah? I have my doubts. I wouldn't take him #1, ESP when you factor he wont be ready til Dec (Best Case scenario). So he comes in having hopefully put on weight, just beginning to play ball with new teammates, and we're hopefully playing playoff caliber ball how is he going to fit in? I'd take Porter and call it a day. Guy is a leader defensively and has put his team on his back during college career. No brainer.
sigh..I see you totally ignored my post in the other thread about Noel's playing weight being very similar to other current NBA all-star caliber centers when they came into the league. Also, Howard weighs 265, not 280. Im surprised you can remember clear back to the first half of Noah's freshman season at Florida, since we are comparing that point in their college careers. He averaged 3.9 pts/game his freshman year, by the way. Also only weighs 232 at 28 yrs old, and I'd say he's doing just fine. You sound ridiculous acting like a 19yr old with not even a half of a year in a good weight program wont transform his body like every other NBA rookie.