LJ;986492 wrote:Not to mention Herbie himself was a horrid QB and had terrible mechanics
Again, being a great player =/= being a great coach. Joe Daniels never played quarterback in his life, yet he was Dan Marino's QB coach in college, he coach Troy Smith to a Heisman Trophy, and was QB coach for three different NFL teams. Think about the greatest golf coaches in the world (Butch Harmon, Hank Haney, David Ledbetter), none of these guys were champion golfers, but they understand the mechanics of the golf swing and how to teach it. Some people don't necessarily have the physical ability to be great, but that doesn't mean that they don't understand what to do and have the ability to teach it, just like some people have the ability to play, but can't necessarily coach. Besides, it is possible that Herbie has learned a thing or two in the 20 years since he played the game.
Now, I don't think Herbie is going to come and coach at OSU, nor do I want him to, but I still don't understand why everyone thinks you have to have been a great player in order to be able to be a great coach.