Ironman92
Posts: 49,363
Dec 27, 2010 11:50pm
Refs gave Saints a 1 yard extra on a 2nd down play wiht just 1:36 left in the game...gave them 3rd and 1 inch...should have been 3rd and a solid 1 yard.
BUT the Falcons blew it...fumbled on the 1 on 2nd down in the 1st half. Then, just like the Jets were 4th and 6 with 2 TO and just over 2:40 to play and punted from about their 40.......THEN the Saints get the ball and quickly get a 1st down with 2:05 on the clock......Falcons allow clock to go down to 2:00 warning which would've cost them a few seconds which could've very much mattered...had they not gotten the 1st down which was aided by the poor spot.
That play and spot was huge in the grand scheme of things....the offical upstairs has to signal down to replay that spot...too big of a situation in too big of a game for that spot to stand.
Again...the falcons have no one to blame but themselves...but the refs messed up late too.
BUT the Falcons blew it...fumbled on the 1 on 2nd down in the 1st half. Then, just like the Jets were 4th and 6 with 2 TO and just over 2:40 to play and punted from about their 40.......THEN the Saints get the ball and quickly get a 1st down with 2:05 on the clock......Falcons allow clock to go down to 2:00 warning which would've cost them a few seconds which could've very much mattered...had they not gotten the 1st down which was aided by the poor spot.
That play and spot was huge in the grand scheme of things....the offical upstairs has to signal down to replay that spot...too big of a situation in too big of a game for that spot to stand.
Again...the falcons have no one to blame but themselves...but the refs messed up late too.
THE4RINGZ
Posts: 16,816
Dec 27, 2010 11:52pm
So they didn't cover?
B
Be Nice
Posts: 1,120
Dec 27, 2010 11:53pm
I saw the play. His knee was down and yes refs are ghey.
Hb31187
Posts: 8,534
Dec 27, 2010 11:55pm
Should I pull a Steelers fan and blame it on the refs? 
Haha oh well, not a big loss. Just gotta beat the shitty Panthers next week and its home field throughout
Haha oh well, not a big loss. Just gotta beat the shitty Panthers next week and its home field throughout
Skyhook79
Posts: 5,739
Dec 27, 2010 11:58pm
The spot wasn't reviewable besides the Saints gained 2 yds on the next play anyways.
Falcons should have never punted the ball back to the Saints.
Falcons should have never punted the ball back to the Saints.
Pick6
Posts: 14,946
Dec 27, 2010 11:59pm
the knee was down and he was a yard short. who cares though, it wouldnt of mattered. he got the first down by a couple yards on the next play
jspitaleri
Posts: 161
Dec 28, 2010 12:00am
Said they couldn't review it because the spot did not result in a first down. That is dumb... either the spot is right or it isn't. The purpose of the review is to get calls correct. Oh well, I still think the Falcons get the #1 seed and win the NFC.
Non
Posts: 9,517
Dec 28, 2010 12:12am
I'm usually more conservative but I would've gone for it there.
It was 4th and 6 right?
Matt Ryan is supposed to be one of the elite QBs. That's not that hard to pick up when you have a great QB.
And even if the Saints get the ball at midfield and add a FG it's 20-14 and you're still not totally out of it.
It was 4th and 6 right?
Matt Ryan is supposed to be one of the elite QBs. That's not that hard to pick up when you have a great QB.
And even if the Saints get the ball at midfield and add a FG it's 20-14 and you're still not totally out of it.
Commander of Awesome
Posts: 23,151
Dec 28, 2010 8:05am
Skyhook79;615362 wrote:Falcons should have never punted the ball back to the Saints.
Agreed, coaching mistake. I dont care how well the defense has played, thats Drew Brees running that offense as the defending super bowl champs.
M
mhs95_06
Posts: 8,167
Dec 28, 2010 11:08am
Very similar to the Jets game in Chicago as far the punt choice.
http://andy-benoit.blogs.cbssports.com/mcc/blogs/entry/22475988/26690425
The above says the win probability going for it on 4th and 6 is 23% vs. 15% if they punt.
http://andy-benoit.blogs.cbssports.com/mcc/blogs/entry/22475988/26690425
The above says the win probability going for it on 4th and 6 is 23% vs. 15% if they punt.
Ironman92
Posts: 49,363
Dec 28, 2010 11:51am
No one cares about percentages....just do what everyone has always done....even though it works less often.
Still wonder why the Falcons didn't call a TO after the first down with between 2:05-2:09 remaining.......had they stopped the Saints that was enough wasted time for one more play.
I don't understand how coaches can work 80+ hours a week on stuff and then not understand clock management to the fullest.
Falcons fumbling on the 1 yard line on 2nd down....yikes. They were jinxed twice by the announers....first they said Michael Turner had over 400 carries without afumble.,....and then said the Saints have given up points 90 straight times when opponent as on the 1.
At 11-4 the Saints are still at the mercy of the god awful Panthers beating the Falcons or they'll by the #5 seed......and maybe then will be the most favored #5 seed in the first round game ever.
Still wonder why the Falcons didn't call a TO after the first down with between 2:05-2:09 remaining.......had they stopped the Saints that was enough wasted time for one more play.
I don't understand how coaches can work 80+ hours a week on stuff and then not understand clock management to the fullest.
Falcons fumbling on the 1 yard line on 2nd down....yikes. They were jinxed twice by the announers....first they said Michael Turner had over 400 carries without afumble.,....and then said the Saints have given up points 90 straight times when opponent as on the 1.
At 11-4 the Saints are still at the mercy of the god awful Panthers beating the Falcons or they'll by the #5 seed......and maybe then will be the most favored #5 seed in the first round game ever.