2018 College Football Thread

posted by Ironman92

ND and LSU lose today

Book it

If USC could finish a drive, this would have been spot on. 

posted by superman

If USC could finish a drive, this would have been spot on. 

I knew better...thisis clearly ND’s year to lose 41-14 in the playoff in a game that felt like 56-7 but refs and luck

Carolina is bringing back Mack Brown 🤦🏻‍♂️

Sounds like Brohm is leaving Purdue. After saying all week he’s staying at Purdue. College coaches are funny. 

posted by SportsAndLady

Sounds like Brohm is leaving Purdue. After saying all week he’s staying at Purdue. College coaches are funny. 

?? He turned Louisville down. 

posted by wildcats20

?? He turned Louisville down. 

He was trending on twitter, first few things I saw said he was telling his players he’s leaving. 

20 min later, it’s announced he’s staying at Purdue. Lol

derp on me 

This 8 team playoff stuff is annoying. Dan Patrick keeps discussing it, the Big 10 and Fox are not going to give up millions in ticket sales and ad sales so schools can host a playoff game

posted by Classyposter58

This 8 team playoff stuff is annoying. Dan Patrick keeps discussing it, the Big 10 and Fox are not going to give up millions in ticket sales and ad sales so schools can host a playoff game

THe problem is there is no "answer".  Pre-BCS, no one liked the fact that there wasn't a championship game.  BCS - championship game teams depended upon voting.  Four team playoff - 5th team is not happy.  8 team playoff - 9th team won't be happy.  16 team playoff - 17th team won't be happy, etc.  

posted by Dr Winston O'Boogie

THe problem is there is no "answer".  Pre-BCS, no one liked the fact that there wasn't a championship game.  BCS - championship game teams depended upon voting.  Four team playoff - 5th team is not happy.  8 team playoff - 9th team won't be happy.  16 team playoff - 17th team won't be happy, etc.  

unfortunately this is true--how long before we go the FCS route?

To me, 8 is the perfect number. Put the conference winners of the Power 5 in and a couple of fringe teams. 16 is too many. Six might even be decent.

Does anyone else listen to golic and wingo? Does anyone else think trey wingo is a huge tool?

posted by SportsAndLady

Does anyone else listen to golic and wingo? Does anyone else think trey wingo is a huge tool?

Most of those guys are. If TJ Houshmanzadeh were standing in front of me, right now, after what he said about Mayfield, I'd be tempted to try to knock him out.

posted by SportsAndLady

Does anyone else listen to golic and wingo? Does anyone else think trey wingo is a huge tool?

count me as another who thinks so too--he tries too damn hard to be 'hip', and he won't shut up when others are talking...the only reason I listen to G&W is because the only other sports related show on my drive to work in the a.m. is Clay Travis, and he's unbearable--I'd rather listen to nothing than listen to that clown.

posted by Dr Winston O'Boogie

THe problem is there is no "answer".  Pre-BCS, no one liked the fact that there wasn't a championship game.  BCS - championship game teams depended upon voting.  Four team playoff - 5th team is not happy.  8 team playoff - 9th team won't be happy.  16 team playoff - 17th team won't be happy, etc.  

they might complain but it would fall on def ears.  The 17th ranked team in any given year is a 3 loss dog.  The 8th team every year is a legit contender that deserves a shot at knocking off someone.  My guess is that we would see the 8 seed knock off the one seed within the first few years.  This isnt the 16 seed versus the 1 seed in bball

To me, if it’s 6, I’ll never complain. Win your conference and you get in. STFU if you don’t. Don’t care if a 5-loss Northwestern makes it over 1-loss Georgia etc. Win your conference...everyone has that ability/chance.

posted by Laley23

Win your conference and you get in. STFU if you don’t. 

/thread

posted by Laley23

To me, if it’s 6, I’ll never complain. Win your conference and you get in. STFU if you don’t. Don’t care if a 5-loss Northwestern makes it over 1-loss Georgia etc. Win your conference...everyone has that ability/chance.

I'm not a fan of that....not all conferences are created equal.  Outside of the Big 12, no other conference plays a true round robin format where each team gets a shot at all other teams in that conference.  Even if they expand, I want them to choose the best teams, regardless of conference affiliation.  

posted by slingshot4ever

I'm not a fan of that....not all conferences are created equal.  Outside of the Big 12, no other conference plays a true round robin format where each team gets a shot at all other teams in that conference.  Even if they expand, I want them to choose the best teams, regardless of conference affiliation.  

You make a valid point, but IMO, there has to be a reward for winning your conference. That being said, when they expand I think it should be 8 teams--the conference champions from the Power 5 with three at-large bids.

posted by slingshot4ever

I'm not a fan of that....not all conferences are created equal.  Outside of the Big 12, no other conference plays a true round robin format where each team gets a shot at all other teams in that conference.  Even if they expand, I want them to choose the best teams, regardless of conference affiliation.  

posted by vball10set

You make a valid point, but IMO, there has to be a reward for winning your conference. That being said, when they expand I think it should be 8 teams--the conference champions from the Power 5 with three at-large bids.

I think those points (want the best teams AND winning a conference should matter) both say that 8 teams is FAR better than 6. Well, that and the simple fact that there's no real logistic difference between 6 and 8. You'll still have 1 additional round of playoffs, the only difference is that the two teams arbitrarily picked to be 1 and 2 by the committee would not have byes). To me, saying that simply because a decent NW team or blah Pitt team took advantage of being in a weak division and then caught lightning in a bottle for one day, so they're more deserving over a team that was legit all year long but had one bad day or was the second-best team in a loaded division is flawed, but at least with an 8-team playoff with 5 champs and three wild cards, there'd be some leeway for those "legit except for one day" teams where the best of them would get in.

posted by slingshot4ever

I'm not a fan of that....not all conferences are created equal.  Outside of the Big 12, no other conference plays a true round robin format where each team gets a shot at all other teams in that conference.  Even if they expand, I want them to choose the best teams, regardless of conference affiliation.  

Sure they do. You play in everyone your division, so win it. Then win the title game. It’s the only absolute to make it work. Otherwise, whonis to say Wisconsin isn’t better than Georgia in a given year even if they have 2 more losses. I can argue the B1G is tougher. Just win the conference and get in. Everyone has that chance.