Who makes your personal sports Mt Rushmore? It doesn't matter the sport, how good they actually were, or your reasons for picking them.
Barry Larkin - favorite player growing up, went to Cooperstown for his induction
Joey Votto - favorite player of the last decade, love his weird personality almost as much as his playing ability
Nick Mangold - always liked him at OSU even though I wasn't a fan of the team, glad the Jets drafted him and he had a hell of a career
Ken Griffey Jr - always loved him as a kid, named our Jack Russell Terrier after him growing up. I was extremely excited when the Reds traded for him, even though it really didn't work out well in the end.